Should We Be Betting on Mobile TV?
Thursday, March 27th, 2008This panel at the Future of Television conference focused on the state of Mobile TV and its chances for success. How is it doing? What is needed for breakout success?
Panelists
Bill Sanders, VP Mobile Programming & Digital Development, Sony Pictures Television
Derek Broes, SVP Worldwide Business Development, Paramount Pictures
Steve Smith, Managing Director, Playboy TV International
Douglas Craig, SVP Digital Media Operations, Discovery Communications
Seamus McAteer, Chief Product Architect & Senior Analyst, Media Metrics
Moderator: Ted Cohen, Managing Partner, TAG Strategic
What are the gating factors for Mobile TV acceptance?
Hasn’t been an overwhelming response for adopting Mobile TV. Insufficient marketing to consumers; marketing is not the carriers’ core competence, just as software development is not the core competence of studios. The numbers are still small - one or two percent - of the mobile phone market in US and Europe, but it’s meaningful, and five to ten percent of the addressable market of video-capable handsets. The combination of flat rate data with increasing video capable handset and YouTube-like free video should be powerful drivers of adoption. If it’s free, everyone will try it at least once.

What are the major content and user interface issues?
Need to build products and services in the way that our kids want, not based on the constraints that we place on them. Examples of limitations: content deleted after 24 hours, inability to pause and come back to content later. Short form is performing better than long form, of course. Foreign language is an issue - need dubbing, subtitles don’t work on mobile (Sony does subtitle, though). Every panelist is doing a combination of repurposing existing and developing original content.
Whether long or short form, it’s about building habit — people returning to the brand again and again. For example, Sony did 200 Ripley Believe It or Not clips. Traditional carrier approach, put them all out there on the shelf and let them die a quiet death. Bill is pushing to go back to original comic strip format, thirty seconds every day with a shelf life. Perishability is important to drive habit building. On YouTube, you want to be the person who discovers the clip and forwards it to your friends. This is something that we should have learned from traditional media.
On digital rights, the most important lesson is that the consumer will do what’s convenient whether it’s legal or not; we need to get in front of the needs and offer what consumers want legally. Should you ask for permission first or forgiveness later? With talent, ask for permission. In other cases, bias toward asking for forgiveness.
What will make Mobile TV prime-time, with DVR- and HD-like uptake?
Forcing the issue on studios and other content owners by device users figuring out how to get the content on the devices. These mobile devices increasingly have the capability of PCs, access to broadband networks, and the ability to sync with PCs.
What about the opportunity for direct-to-consumer, internet / browser based mobile portals, bypassing operators?
Hard to market and reach consumers without carrier support. However, YouTube has some success in mobile. Operators are very concerned about this, want to stay well ahead of it. Also, trying to convince carriers that they can be “smart pipes” without being the programmer, e.g. billing relationship.
Hallelujah! In a move long overdue, Verizon announced that it will be opening up its network to “Any App, Any Device” by the end of 2008. I can’t wait to see how it rolls out and whether we can publish podcasts to phones as easily as we can to the Nokia phones. Digital Podcast has provided ongoing support the
I sat down with Derrick Oien, the President and Co-founder of 












