Andrew and Alex joined Forrester Research for its 2008 Marketing Forum. This article is the second in our series from the forum focused on customer engagement in a digital media world.

Realizing Your Return on Empathy (ROE)

Steve Kerho, VP Analytics, Organic
Mark Kingdon, CEO, Organic
Creating effective online (and offline) marketing solutions starts with a deep, emotional understanding of your customer segments and their needs – in other words, “empathy” for your customer “personas”. This empathy serves as a critical guide in designing online and other touchpoints, and the personas also support breaking down how you measure and respond to online performance.

Mark led off the sessions with the observation that as marketers, we have a lot of data about customers, but we need to get beyond the data to “touch” our customers.

He then solicited audience feedback on the importance of understanding customers in marketing through a uniquely engaging technique. When we sat down in the conference room, a pad and a branded pen were keeping each of our seats warm. The pens were laser pointers, and Mark gave us a brief tutorial on turning them on and aiming them without blinding our neighbors.

Mark walked us through a series of slides filled with questions and multiple choice “answer” targets; the volume of laser points bouncing around each target quickly illuminated audience response. The survey responses told us that collectively, we thought it important to find an edge in our marketing and to develop and understand customer personas to refine marketing approaches, but that we had a way to go in implementing these techniques.

Organic believes that getting to personas is so fundamental to their work that each year they send staff down to Vegas for “persona work”. The group breaks down into seven teams that are each assigned one of seven sins. Each team is tasked with observing people indulging in their target sin, and then developing a campaign for that persona. The exercise is all about getting to empathy, getting everyone on the same song sheet around what’s driving the consumer, their behavior and their needs.

Organic sees four steps in order to take advantage of empathy:

(1) Know your consumers well enough to develop detailed personas,
(2) Design web experiences around those personas,
(3) Tailor all media and touchpoints to these personas, and
(4) Know and optimize against “Return on Empathy”.

To get to step 4, marketing needs to secure management commitment to overcoming the challenges of siloed organizations, to develop a process for optimizing efforts, and to connect campaign objectives to metrics.

Why go through all this effort? Because empathy pays off, as Steve demonstrated with three case studies:

Jeep Patriot. The business objectives were to create familiarity and purchase intent for this all new vehicle in a crowded segment, targeting younger, internet saavy buyers. The solution was a very interactive online experience, where they shot 40 or so minute-long video segments for about the cost of a traditional 30 second spot. These segments comprise an interactive film, which viewers could enter and then steer their experience and outcome. Consumers were introduced to the story starting with a TV broadcast spot, then rich online ads, targeted emails, and theatrical trailers. In total their was about an hour of content, and the vehicle and its features appear in every scene. Their campaign had great results – Jeep more than doubled its target for unique visitors, with 80% of them new to the Jeep brand, enjoying an average viewing time of 5 minutes with 40% of visitors staying for over 10 minutes.

Bank of America’s No Fee Mortgage Plus product. The business objectives were to create familiarity, awareness and sell-through. They identified one persona familiar with the mortgage process, and another unfamiliar with it, and customized the site experience accordingly after three very simple multiple choice pre-qualifying questions.

Coach. The business objective was to increase the sales of bags online. The empathy process highlighted a key “persona” issue around women’s discomfort buying bags unless they are sure that they fit. The solution was to create an online bag “sizer” that drove a substantial increase in sales and reduction in returns.

After the case studies, Steve walked us through an example of metrics supporting “ROE” on site design. The example showed how the measures were built up, and demonstrated the differential impact on return against identified personas versus non-personas.

The session was running late so there wasn’t much time to discuss the ROI calculations, below.  Deeper reflection reveals a number of interesting questions, for example, why calculate ROI based on revenue rather than contribution margin, why only amortize the redesign over one quarter, and whether the redesign impacted other drivers of value such as new customer acquisition and retention rates.  You might choose a different set of assumptions for your business, but in any case, the persona-level analysis of differential site performance provides an important basis for objectively evaluating ROI.

The bottom line: executed well, empathy pays.

Q&A Discussion

You mentioned that the Jeep example exceeded traffic goals, but how does one go about establishing those goals? You end up in the forecasting business, and need to use historical performance offline and online as the baseline that you are trying to meet or exceed, for example CPM through traditional media (even though may be lower engagement, more eyeballs) You can also look at search traffic and value as another baseline for the value of the consumers you bring in.

How difficult is it to sell-in the work of building personas to clients? Actually, doing so in increasingly easy, and we have had some clients asking only for personas, not the follow-on work.

What is the role of customers in participating in site design? Customers are an increasingly important part of the process. In fact, we are working with a client now to involve customers in their core product development process.

How are you developing personas beyond traditional observations? We have deliberately selected low-tech workshops versus high tech means to develop personas, which surprises many because so much of what we do is high tech. That approach may evolve over time.

Does all this work to actually increase sales? Our clients have realized a high correlation between engagement, purchase intent, and buying behavior.